The Bitches of Eastwick
A friend, in her article, said that Indonesians are a bit thin-skinned when it comes to criticism. Being a not-so-regular-anymore reviewer at the paper, I couldn't agree more with her.
Although they never say it to my face, I always heard that this designer, or that filmmaker(s) is not pleased with my reviews. As far as I'm concerned, my reviews have always been objective and never personal, so why do they have to be mad? Shouldn't they be glad to receive feedback?
Besides, compare to the style of foreign media when they give reviews, mine certainly are more mellow :)
I know a writer who never talks to his friend, a poet/writer, ever again as the latter wrote a negative review in a national magazine upon the former's theater production.
As for me, as long as it's not personal (like my weight:) ) I'm open for criticism. I'm used anyway to have my ass kicked or being yelled at by editors when I wrote crap.
Funny thing happened last weekend. Joko asked me to accompany him to a launching of the Indonesian film catalog at a bookstore. I didn't feel like joining the crowd, so I browsed the store instead and bought a book.
As we headed out of the store, Joko told me that film producer ML asked about me when she knew Joko was coming with me. I'd heard from some people that she and director RR (what am I doing here actually by giving initials? heh heh) were furious as I bashed their latest film. You know, that biopic about political activist *wink wink*.
Just when we walked out of the door, we saw ML in the parking lot, which meant it was impossible to avoid her. So, we greeted her casually. She, however, screamed in a rather high pitched noise, and pointed to us alternately "Hey, it's the bitches! The bitches! The bitches 01 (Joko) and the bitches 02 (me)! Or is it the other way around?" she shouted, while still pointing and shouted the b word.
We didn't know how to react, so we just grinned, while wondering whether she was joking or not. But then she cracked a laugh, and so did we.
See? We should just be able to laugh about it instead of shooting the critics and take it too seriously. Although, I bet Ms. ML still holds grudge, but I hope I'm wrong.
Although they never say it to my face, I always heard that this designer, or that filmmaker(s) is not pleased with my reviews. As far as I'm concerned, my reviews have always been objective and never personal, so why do they have to be mad? Shouldn't they be glad to receive feedback?
Besides, compare to the style of foreign media when they give reviews, mine certainly are more mellow :)
I know a writer who never talks to his friend, a poet/writer, ever again as the latter wrote a negative review in a national magazine upon the former's theater production.
As for me, as long as it's not personal (like my weight:) ) I'm open for criticism. I'm used anyway to have my ass kicked or being yelled at by editors when I wrote crap.
Funny thing happened last weekend. Joko asked me to accompany him to a launching of the Indonesian film catalog at a bookstore. I didn't feel like joining the crowd, so I browsed the store instead and bought a book.
As we headed out of the store, Joko told me that film producer ML asked about me when she knew Joko was coming with me. I'd heard from some people that she and director RR (what am I doing here actually by giving initials? heh heh) were furious as I bashed their latest film. You know, that biopic about political activist *wink wink*.
Just when we walked out of the door, we saw ML in the parking lot, which meant it was impossible to avoid her. So, we greeted her casually. She, however, screamed in a rather high pitched noise, and pointed to us alternately "Hey, it's the bitches! The bitches! The bitches 01 (Joko) and the bitches 02 (me)! Or is it the other way around?" she shouted, while still pointing and shouted the b word.
We didn't know how to react, so we just grinned, while wondering whether she was joking or not. But then she cracked a laugh, and so did we.
See? We should just be able to laugh about it instead of shooting the critics and take it too seriously. Although, I bet Ms. ML still holds grudge, but I hope I'm wrong.

